When to contact Tower as per VNC
Moderators: sky's the limit, sepia, Sulako, Right Seat Captain, lilfssister, North Shore
When to contact Tower as per VNC
Sorry if this is a pretty newbie question; I was talking with my instructor the other day and he asked me if I had to contact Saskatoon ATC if I was following the below track. I said no only if I wished to enter the class D CZ. He said that was incorrect, I had to contact ATC prior to entering the terminal area of Saskatoon. From the VNC, I do not see any requirement to contact ATC. Is there anyway to determine this requirement from the VNC? Winnipeg terminal area contact requirements is defined very clearly on the VNC as well as the TAC but not so much for the Saskatoon.
- Attachments
-
- saskatoon.JPG (265.39 KiB) Viewed 2499 times
-
- Rank 4
- Posts: 203
- Joined: Fri Sep 06, 2019 2:05 pm
Re: When to contact Tower as per VNC
Are you cruising between 700 and 2900? If so, you're in the class E transition, no?
Last edited by Pilotdaddy on Wed Feb 26, 2020 9:33 am, edited 1 time in total.
Re: When to contact Tower as per VNC
From what i can see in every chart i have, you wouldn't need permission to enter the class E Airspace.
However i would recommend talking to Tower or Centre in order to have traffic separation from the aircraft transitioning to and from the training areas denoted to the south, and from any IFR traffic on approach.
However i would recommend talking to Tower or Centre in order to have traffic separation from the aircraft transitioning to and from the training areas denoted to the south, and from any IFR traffic on approach.
Re: When to contact Tower as per VNC
Actually I would be at 5500. It's just that I don't see any specific indication on the VNC to contact Saskatoon. If you go down to Regina its the same exact airspace but there is no requirement to contact Regina unless you are planning on entering the control CZ. I agree it would be wise either way to get traffic separation.
Re: When to contact Tower as per VNC
It's class E, no requirement for a clearance or for radio contact VFR. Best practice would be to request flight following but that's up to the specific controller, if they say no then you just proceed no contact anyway.
Re: When to contact Tower as per VNC
To clarify: you were flight planning a VFR flight, right?
As an AvCanada discussion grows longer:
-the probability of 'entitlement' being mentioned, approaches 1
-one will be accused of using bad airmanship
-the probability of 'entitlement' being mentioned, approaches 1
-one will be accused of using bad airmanship
Re: When to contact Tower as per VNC
Yep, this was just for flight planning for the CPL flight test Nav portion. Well I'm glad to see I'm not going crazy as it is clearly class E. My instructor seemed pretty adamant that you had to talk to someone though. He's a great instructor and is the kinda guy who considers best practice a standing rule so maybe that's what he was getting at.
Re: When to contact Tower as per VNC
Ask him to show you where it says you need to contact ATC, or if it's just a recommendation to get flight following. Like others have said, I don't see any requirement.Spinwmts wrote: ↑Wed Feb 26, 2020 10:02 am Yep, this was just for flight planning for the CPL flight test Nav portion. Well I'm glad to see I'm not going crazy as it is clearly class E. My instructor seemed pretty adamant that you had to talk to someone though. He's a great instructor and is the kinda guy who considers best practice a standing rule so maybe that's what he was getting at.
Re: When to contact Tower as per VNC
Yeah I'll definitely do that. Thanks!
-
- Rank 4
- Posts: 203
- Joined: Fri Sep 06, 2019 2:05 pm
Re: When to contact Tower as per VNC
Right... Class E doesn't need radio comms. I was thinking it's a controlled airspace hence radio comms. I know that ATC provides traffic separation for IFR aircraft, but without comms, is it safe to say that VFR traffic in class E isn't controlled?
-
- Rank 4
- Posts: 203
- Joined: Fri Sep 06, 2019 2:05 pm
Re: When to contact Tower as per VNC
Side topic, where's a good boundary when it's recommended to contact ATC when merely just passing through and not landing on a class D? Passing through 1000ft above the control zone, will a call be recommended? What about 2000ft? What about passing through to the side say 10NM outside of the class D radius?
- TurkeyFarmYQX
- Rank 2
- Posts: 94
- Joined: Sun Oct 08, 2017 5:38 am
Re: When to contact Tower as per VNC
I usually will contact tower within 2000ft over their zone and within 10 miles of the tower.
Re: When to contact Tower as per VNC
If you already have flight following, dont bother calling the tower. You already have tfc advisories, and Ctr and Twr know what each other are doing (for the most part).Pilotdaddy wrote: ↑Wed Feb 26, 2020 11:36 am Side topic, where's a good boundary when it's recommended to contact ATC when merely just passing through and not landing on a class D? Passing through 1000ft above the control zone, will a call be recommended? What about 2000ft? What about passing through to the side say 10NM outside of the class D radius?
If you are just on 126.7 and passing by, i'd consider monitoring twr fq within 10nm, as this is where most initial fixes s are for the RNAV approaches into most airports. As for contacting them if you're just passing by, no hard rules, but if they sound overloaded - stay out of their way, they know youre there. If nothing is happening on fq, i'd give them a courtesy call and position report.
I've had mixed experiences calling class C and D towers when just passing by. Some have been helpful and thanked me for tuning in, and others have told me to f*ck off because i'm not in their airspace. So now i follow my guide above.
Re: When to contact Tower as per VNC
Yeah I've had similar experiences . I would be more likely to call them up if I were over flying their CZ. I tend to only call up when its required now. When I was flying in the states flight following was encouraged which allowed you to transit through pretty hectic airspace. Once I got cleared right over Dulles Airport (Class B) as a student pilot. That was pretty sweet!
-
- Rank 4
- Posts: 203
- Joined: Fri Sep 06, 2019 2:05 pm
Re: When to contact Tower as per VNC
Thanks Dople.
Spin, are you implying that radar services are not encouraged here in Canada? And how did you make it all the way there as a student pilot? Guessing you did your training there?
Spin, are you implying that radar services are not encouraged here in Canada? And how did you make it all the way there as a student pilot? Guessing you did your training there?
Re: When to contact Tower as per VNC
Yeah its definitely been my experience that flight following (at least in the Prairies) is not encouraged. I've heard some folks out east say it is used it a little more (Toronto area etc). I started flying and got my PPL down there then came up here after meeting a girl. But in the states if you were training, it was SOP to tune to flight following after departure and stick with them for all XC flights.
Re: When to contact Tower as per VNC
That's because in big parts of the prairie provinces, there *is* no low level radar...
As an AvCanada discussion grows longer:
-the probability of 'entitlement' being mentioned, approaches 1
-one will be accused of using bad airmanship
-the probability of 'entitlement' being mentioned, approaches 1
-one will be accused of using bad airmanship
Re: When to contact Tower as per VNC
The US has no equivalent to 126.7 or regional Common Traffic Advisory Frequencies.
Even around Toronto - as soon as you're 45 minutes north of the GTA you're off the radar at the height of a typical student cross country, and no flight following is available. Turning the radio off and just flying with your eyes open can be an unalloyed pleasure.
DId you hear the one about the jurisprudence fetishist? He got off on a technicality.
Re: When to contact Tower as per VNC
There's a difference between "good practices" and the law, and there should always be a clear differentiation between the two. Either your instructor doesn't know how to read the chart, doesn't know what Class E is, or is blurring the lines between things when they really should not be blurred. A less knowledgeable student would take the wrong lesson out of this exchange, and wouldn't understand the rules going forward.Spinwmts wrote: ↑Wed Feb 26, 2020 10:02 am Yep, this was just for flight planning for the CPL flight test Nav portion. Well I'm glad to see I'm not going crazy as it is clearly class E. My instructor seemed pretty adamant that you had to talk to someone though. He's a great instructor and is the kinda guy who considers best practice a standing rule so maybe that's what he was getting at.
Re: When to contact Tower as per VNC
Flight instructor and Class C ATC here, my 2 bits.
It is solidly Class E, no contact is required. However, at your selected cruising altitude you would be flying through an approach that may be active, hence the Mode C requirement. I would teach my flight students that a courtesy call to the tower would be in order, it will get you an altimeter setting and ask for winds as well.
It is solidly Class E, no contact is required. However, at your selected cruising altitude you would be flying through an approach that may be active, hence the Mode C requirement. I would teach my flight students that a courtesy call to the tower would be in order, it will get you an altimeter setting and ask for winds as well.