Would having gone skydiving or even wingsuiting before make someone a better pilot?
Moderators: sky's the limit, sepia, Sulako, lilfssister, North Shore, I WAS Birddog
-
- Rank 5
- Posts: 344
- Joined: Mon Apr 13, 2015 7:04 pm
Would having gone skydiving or even wingsuiting before make someone a better pilot?
Should every pilot try it? Someone recently told me they closed their eyes for the whole thing. Haven’t tried it (you never “try” at skydiving), but the whole thing thing just seems sketchy to me anyways.
Re: Would having gone skydiving or even wingsuiting before make someone a better pilot?
In my opinion, no. If people want to skydive, then do that, but not as the basis of building piloting skills. To be honest, you'd learn more about flying standing around chatting with the jump pilots in between jumps. So if your goal is to learn about flying at a parachuting school, go to the school, and don't bother with the jumping part, you'll have more opportunity to talk to pilots, and less risk of a jump accident!
Re: Would having gone skydiving or even wingsuiting before make someone a better pilot?
What he said. I did it, eye's weren't closed but I did go solo not tandem and it was a static line (only 4000ft up and much like army paratroopers your chute is pulled by a line... or the instructor as you head out the door) so it was only 4-5 seconds of free fall but all I remember is tumbling. After the chute opens its quiet and calm and cool and I suppose SOME basics of flight as you are basically a small glider and do need to flare on landing to not snap a femur as one of our group did. Great fun, would love to try a wing suit but I do realize its an advanced technique and I would smear myself over a cliffside so I'll stick to youtube
-
- Rank 7
- Posts: 639
- Joined: Thu Nov 06, 2008 5:17 pm
- Location: The Okanagan
Re: Would having gone skydiving or even wingsuiting before make someone a better pilot?
"...wingsuiting (make) a better pilot?"
I doubt it, but the reverse is true...
I doubt it, but the reverse is true...
Re: Would having gone skydiving or even wingsuiting before make someone a better pilot?
I have been skydiving (static line jumps up through 60 second freefalls) and consider myself a competent pilot. I wouldn't say skydiving helped.
I will say that skydiving is a hell of a lot of fun. If you're interested in it, give it a go. It's only money.
I will say that skydiving is a hell of a lot of fun. If you're interested in it, give it a go. It's only money.
Re: Would having gone skydiving or even wingsuiting before make someone a better pilot?
I have 110 jumps. Started out as a jump pilot and got my first jump course for free. Liked it so much I kept on doing it. I suppose anything aviation related makes you more knowledgeable and skydiving bith in freefall and under canopy is a learning experience. But the biggest thing you will be more knowledgeable about will be knowing about skydiving ops which could be useful when flying in the vicinity of skydiving airports such as where they will likely be jumping out of the aircraft relative to the airport.
For example, if you are going to pass nearby the airport, it might be better to pass on the downwind side of the airport rather than the upwind side where the jumpers usually do their freefalling. Similar to glider ops. Just remember that this is usually the way it is not always. As for making you a better pilot, it is just one more experience that you have operating an airfoil. If that is considered making you a better pilot, then the answer is yes.
For example, if you are going to pass nearby the airport, it might be better to pass on the downwind side of the airport rather than the upwind side where the jumpers usually do their freefalling. Similar to glider ops. Just remember that this is usually the way it is not always. As for making you a better pilot, it is just one more experience that you have operating an airfoil. If that is considered making you a better pilot, then the answer is yes.
-
- Rank 8
- Posts: 844
- Joined: Mon Feb 16, 2009 3:50 pm
Re: Would having gone skydiving or even wingsuiting before make someone a better pilot?
Where’s the wingsuit wonder when you need him?
Re: Would having gone skydiving or even wingsuiting before make someone a better pilot?
China
-
- Rank 5
- Posts: 345
- Joined: Thu Apr 05, 2018 1:12 pm
Re: Would having gone skydiving or even wingsuiting before make someone a better pilot?
He's back.
I feel somewhat qualified to answer the question, as I have some 900+ wingsuit flights.
The answer is no.
I feel somewhat qualified to answer the question, as I have some 900+ wingsuit flights.
The answer is no.
-
- Rank 8
- Posts: 844
- Joined: Mon Feb 16, 2009 3:50 pm
Re: Would having gone skydiving or even wingsuiting before make someone a better pilot?
Isn’t that your 4th username now?
-
- Rank 5
- Posts: 345
- Joined: Thu Apr 05, 2018 1:12 pm
Re: Would having gone skydiving or even wingsuiting before make someone a better pilot?
I think it's the 7th. I started out life here on Avcanada as Jonny Dangerous. But he's dead to me now.
Today I identify as China_CAAC_Exam.
Today I identify as China_CAAC_Exam.
Re: Would having gone skydiving or even wingsuiting before make someone a better pilot?
Ha ha to China-CAAC_Exam
I was an awful skydiver before I completed my first pilot's license. I had two malfunctions in 63 jumps, on the 39th and 41st.
I do think that performance under stressful situations where life is at stake is critical for pilots when those situations arise. So arguably, skydiving might provide some benefit IF one has had emergency situations skydiving. However, a skydiving emergency is dealt with in one or two seconds and is a trained reaction with no decision making involved. Pilots may face stress and complex decision making for many minutes in emergencies. So it's a bit of a stretch to say that in the context of dealing with emergencies, skydiving makes you a better pilot. Implicit in that is that you must have actually had a skydiving emergency.
In a broader sense, any activity with risk that relies on a trained reaction to an emergency through procedures which resolve the emergency probably does make for a better pilot. If you have a belief in good outcomes from good decisions and actions, then you have a better chance of those things resulting when you are faced with difficulties in the air.
I was an awful skydiver before I completed my first pilot's license. I had two malfunctions in 63 jumps, on the 39th and 41st.
I do think that performance under stressful situations where life is at stake is critical for pilots when those situations arise. So arguably, skydiving might provide some benefit IF one has had emergency situations skydiving. However, a skydiving emergency is dealt with in one or two seconds and is a trained reaction with no decision making involved. Pilots may face stress and complex decision making for many minutes in emergencies. So it's a bit of a stretch to say that in the context of dealing with emergencies, skydiving makes you a better pilot. Implicit in that is that you must have actually had a skydiving emergency.
In a broader sense, any activity with risk that relies on a trained reaction to an emergency through procedures which resolve the emergency probably does make for a better pilot. If you have a belief in good outcomes from good decisions and actions, then you have a better chance of those things resulting when you are faced with difficulties in the air.
Good judgment comes from experience. Experience often comes from bad judgment.
-
- Rank 5
- Posts: 344
- Joined: Mon Apr 13, 2015 7:04 pm
Re: Would having gone skydiving or even wingsuiting before make someone a better pilot?
I was just thinking having been wingsuiting before and really tactfully felt the aerodynamic sounds, that that might translate into better feel in an airplane. But I’m grasping for straws here of course.
Re: Would having gone skydiving or even wingsuiting before make someone a better pilot?
In that sense, yes it would make you grasp some aerodynamic concepts, but no more or less than someone sticking his hand out of a car on the highway would.mixturerich wrote: ↑Fri Nov 09, 2018 11:47 pm I was just thinking having been wingsuiting before and really tactfully felt the aerodynamic sounds, that that might translate into better feel in an airplane. But I’m grasping for straws here of course.
I also have some skydiving, wing suiting and jump pilot experience, and like it was mentioned above, any and all time spent in, on and around aircraft and the sky will be beneficial to a point.
Skydive because that's something hou want to do.
58