Set Cruise Power?

This forum has been developed to discuss aviation related topics.

Moderators: sky's the limit, sepia, Sulako, lilfssister, North Shore, I WAS Birddog

User avatar
KAG
Rank 11
Rank 11
Posts: 3619
Joined: Wed Feb 18, 2004 11:24 pm

Re: Set Cruise Power?

Post by KAG »

goldeneagle wrote:
Tim wrote: For those with a real interest in the subject, here's todays homework assignment. Come back and tell us why you would load your airplane either at forward or aft cg limits, to reduce fuel consumption. Assume your cruise will be up near service cieling, operating within 10 knots of the power curve limits (right dead center in the middle of coffin corner), and you are cruising for maximum range, overwater delivery flight. Would you load the a/c forward, or aft, and why ? What techniques would be best for setting optimum cruise conditions ?
Aft C of G, short answer the plane weighs less. Less weight (less downward lift created from the elevator to raise the nose which the wings have to overcome) therefore less power required for a given speed. Less power required, less fuel burned.
---------- ADS -----------
 
The feet you step on today might be attached to the ass you're kissing tomorrow.
Chase lifestyle not metal.
iflyforpie
Top Poster
Top Poster
Posts: 8132
Joined: Tue Apr 15, 2008 12:25 pm
Location: Winterfell...

Re: Set Cruise Power?

Post by iflyforpie »

If you are climbing on the back side of the power curve, you are doing it for two reasons. Either climbing at best angle (Vx) which is slightly on the back side of the power curve or you are trying to use zoom to climb further-robbing Peter to pay Paul IMHO and a poor way to fly a plane.

There is no reason to climb on the back side of the power curve when you are clear of obstacles. Your climb rate will be slower and you will waste more fuel. As an aircraft approaches its absolute ceiling Vx and Vy gradually become equal. At the absolute ceiling the only way to maintain altitude is to fly at Vy/Vx. Any other speed will make you descend.

So if you climb at Vy, level off at Vy, drag only increases with speed. There is no proverbial 'hump' to get over unless you are stuck in induced drag land where you shouldn't have been in the first place.
Maintain thy airspeed lest the earth come up and smite thee
---------- ADS -----------
 
Geez did I say that....? Or just think it....?
ahramin
Rank Moderator
Rank Moderator
Posts: 6326
Joined: Tue Feb 17, 2004 5:21 pm
Location: Vancouver

Re: Set Cruise Power?

Post by ahramin »

So we have this fancy technique of surfing down a couple hundred feet to get on the step and gain 15 knots in cruise, which is only useful if you have terrible technique in the climb.

Makes sense to me, but i think i'll just continue using proper technique in the climb.

But if you fly like the flight 3701 guys it is probably a good idea.
---------- ADS -----------
 
2R
Rank 11
Rank 11
Posts: 4329
Joined: Tue Oct 19, 2004 2:25 pm
Location: left coast

Re: Set Cruise Power?

Post by 2R »

When all else fails read the manual specific to the particular aircraft :mrgreen: :mrgreen:
---------- ADS -----------
 
dgeb
Rank 0
Rank 0
Posts: 13
Joined: Mon Feb 28, 2005 1:40 pm

Re: Set Cruise Power?

Post by dgeb »

The old bush techniques used on DC-3’s for example, would net 15 to 20knt IAS. Every aircraft and condition was different. Airframe degradation – peeling paint; stone chipped props; dented leading edges; and of coarse – silver tape flapping in the wind all contributed to deviations from the Performance Charts.

Step cruising techniques in these cases gave real returns, less airtime ergo lower fuel burns.

Oh, if you have to climb continuously on the back side of the curve, its time to lower the nose and go home.
---------- ADS -----------
 
iflyforpie
Top Poster
Top Poster
Posts: 8132
Joined: Tue Apr 15, 2008 12:25 pm
Location: Winterfell...

Re: Set Cruise Power?

Post by iflyforpie »

There is no aircraft in existence that will climb faster on the back side of the power curve than at Vy. At least for more than 10 seconds.

Since I fly close to the absolute ceiling of my aircraft I use the POH combined with another formula to determine the best speed.

In my case, Vy is about 10 MPH slower IAS at altitude than sea level. For the loading of my plane I use sqrt*(actual weight/max gross weight). In my 206 it takes another 10 MPH off Vy if I am 700lbs under gross.

If you don't adjust the numbers and use the POH sea level max gross figure, you are on the front side of the power curve (basically doing a cruise climb).

Step cruising is good, but climbing 200ft above and then descending to 'ride the wave' or 'get out of the back side of the power curve' is useless if you are climbing correctly. Worn paint, dents, etc, increase parasitic drag, they have virtually no effect on induced drag (where the airflow is already turbulent over the wings and not moving very fast over the fuselage). Poor engines and propellers will shift Vy back making you more in the front side of the power curve.
---------- ADS -----------
 
Geez did I say that....? Or just think it....?
scrambled_legs
Rank 5
Rank 5
Posts: 311
Joined: Sun Dec 11, 2005 4:14 pm

Re: Set Cruise Power?

Post by scrambled_legs »

KAG wrote:
goldeneagle wrote:
Tim wrote: For those with a real interest in the subject, here's todays homework assignment. Come back and tell us why you would load your airplane either at forward or aft cg limits, to reduce fuel consumption. Assume your cruise will be up near service cieling, operating within 10 knots of the power curve limits (right dead center in the middle of coffin corner), and you are cruising for maximum range, overwater delivery flight. Would you load the a/c forward, or aft, and why ? What techniques would be best for setting optimum cruise conditions ?
Aft C of G, short answer the plane weighs less. Less weight (less downward lift created from the elevator to raise the nose which the wings have to overcome) therefore less power required for a given speed. Less power required, less fuel burned.
Just be prepared for a lot of excess trimming in cruise.

A lot of great info in this thread and no insults... what's going on???
---------- ADS -----------
 
goldeneagle
Rank (9)
Rank (9)
Posts: 1364
Joined: Mon Jan 02, 2006 3:28 pm

Re: Set Cruise Power?

Post by goldeneagle »

ahramin wrote:So we have this fancy technique of surfing down a couple hundred feet to get on the step and gain 15 knots in cruise, which is only useful if you have terrible technique in the climb.

Makes sense to me, but i think i'll just continue using proper technique in the climb.

But if you fly like the flight 3701 guys it is probably a good idea.
What are you flying ??

Ever taken something like a canso on a long haul, and dragged it up to the service ceiling? I dont know the numbers for that airplane offhand, but, i'm gonna guess that once you get up around 17000 with it (hey cat, can a canso even get that high?? How many hours will it take?), set at the angle of attack for best l/d its probably indicating something like 120. Let the nose drift up a degree, it'll indicate 110, and start to descend. Let the nose drift down a degree, it'll indicate 125 and descend. The range of useable angles will give a very narrow speed range at which it can maintain level, and an even narrower range where it can still climb.

So tell me, you gonna get that thing all the way up to 17000 hand bombing in turbulence, climbing out over the rocks north of vancouver, enroute to some gawdforsaken little place in the arctic, and not once have the airspeed slip down a few knots, or up a few knots? Then once you get to altitude, remember, there is no autopilot on that old thing, you are gonna sit and hold 120 indicated for the 16 hours worth of fuel it carries, and not once slip back a couple knots, or up a couple knots. you are hand bombing the airplane, at an altitude where the controls are really mushy, and there's a good jag of turbulence today.

Sure, a modern new rvsm autopilot, that's a piece of cake, plus or minus two knots, no problem. But hand flying something with some mass behind it, high enough that the controls are mushy at best.

sometimes I wonder why we even try bring answers to some of the threads here on avcan. There's always somebody that can do it better, knows better, has all the answers, and the perfect technique. Better technique, and another human factors course is the answer to everything.

After I moved to the island, I took a 6 month hiatus from avcan, just started peeking back recently. But, it's getting pretty obvious, after 30 years of flying them, and 20 of those involved in the design side of the industry as well, I have nothing to offer here where there isn't somebody else that knows better, can do better. It's probably time for a permanent haitus, there's no point trying to add anything to conversations here.
---------- ADS -----------
 
Last edited by goldeneagle on Tue Oct 07, 2008 4:45 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
x-wind
Rank 7
Rank 7
Posts: 739
Joined: Sat Mar 26, 2005 10:23 pm
Location: Around

Re: Set Cruise Power?

Post by x-wind »

In some cases I fly the Navajo to 1000agl at Vx. If there is aggressive terrain the further I get from the field.. I may need the 1000 to stay airborne if I loose an engine.

That or some(actually a lot I do) IFR procedures need me at an altitude before I get to a way point. Again back side of the the curve for me.

When we look at obstacle clearing or IFR climb gradients FT per NM is used of course, which if it's tight, is best met with a Vx climb.

KAG, didn't like the "the airplane is lighter with an AFT loading" no it produces less drag. Less weight and less drag are different. Just wanted to mention that.

Best range is had at a Certain A of A. That with engine characteristics taken into account can find the perfect altitude.

Never flown with an A of A indicator but as the stick and rudder book emphasizes we can indirectly find that with the airspeed.

How is best rate determined again? It's not L/D max but usually correlates to a really close A of A. To many factors so they just flt test the crap out of it to figure it?? Excuse my ignorance, not using it so loosing it..
---------- ADS -----------
 
User avatar
Uncomfortable Silence
Rank 1
Rank 1
Posts: 17
Joined: Sat Oct 08, 2005 9:31 pm

Re: Set Cruise Power?

Post by Uncomfortable Silence »

Here's an interesting read regarding the Concorde and it's use of fuel "trim tanks" to maintain the CofG during the transition to/from supersonic cruise due to the shift of the Center of Pressure
At its cruise speed of Mach 2, the center of pressure had moved a full 6 ft (1.8 m) aft of its location at subsonic speeds
http://www.aerospaceweb.org/question/planes/q0199.shtml

To bad goldeneagle...if it hadn't been for the homework assignment I wouldn't have tracked down this tidbit...
---------- ADS -----------
 
If at first you don't succeed, then skydiving definitely isn't for you.
ahramin
Rank Moderator
Rank Moderator
Posts: 6326
Joined: Tue Feb 17, 2004 5:21 pm
Location: Vancouver

Re: Set Cruise Power?

Post by ahramin »

goldeneagle wrote:
ahramin wrote:So we have this fancy technique of surfing down a couple hundred feet to get on the step and gain 15 knots in cruise, which is only useful if you have terrible technique in the climb.

Makes sense to me, but i think i'll just continue using proper technique in the climb.

But if you fly like the flight 3701 guys it is probably a good idea.
What are you flying ??

Ever taken something like a canso on a long haul, and dragged it up to the service ceiling? I dont know the numbers for that airplane offhand, but, i'm gonna guess that once you get up around 17000 with it (hey cat, can a canso even get that high?? How many hours will it take?), set at the angle of attack for best l/d its probably indicating something like 120. Let the nose drift up a degree, it'll indicate 110, and start to descend. Let the nose drift down a degree, it'll indicate 125 and descend. The range of useable angles will give a very narrow speed range at which it can maintain level, and an even narrower range where it can still climb.

So tell me, you gonna get that thing all the way up to 17000 hand bombing in turbulence, climbing out over the rocks north of vancouver, enroute to some gawdforsaken little place in the arctic, and not once have the airspeed slip down a few knots, or up a few knots? Then once you get to altitude, remember, there is no autopilot on that old thing, you are gonna sit and hold 120 indicated for the 16 hours worth of fuel it carries, and not once slip back a couple knots, or up a couple knots. you are hand bombing the airplane, at an altitude where the controls are really mushy, and there's a good jag of turbulence today.

Sure, a modern new rvsm autopilot, that's a piece of cake, plus or minus two knots, no problem. But hand flying something with some mass behind it, high enough that the controls are mushy at best.

sometimes I wonder why we even try bring answers to some of the threads here on avcan. There's always somebody that can do it better, knows better, has all the answers, and the perfect technique. Better technique, and another human factors course is the answer to everything.

After I moved to the island, I took a 6 month hiatus from avcan, just started peeking back recently. But, it's getting pretty obvious, after 30 years of flying them, and 20 of those involved in the design side of the industry as well, I have nothing to offer here where there isn't somebody else that knows better, can do better. It's probably time for a permanent haitus, there's no point trying to add anything to conversations here.
Whatever the service ceiling for the aircraft is, by definition that will be the point at which the aircraft still has enough excess thrust to climb 50 ft per minute. That is a pretty slow climb to get up there. I think I would level off at some lower altitude first. But I have not been flying 30 years so lets say for some reason we keep climbing until we get there. When we level off, that excess thrust will slowly accelerate the aircraft to your speed of 120. Now we have to hold attitude on a Canso within 1 degree or we start to descend. I have not flown a Canso but I will take your word for it that doing this for 16 hours is no fun.

So instead we struggle up to 17 200 feet, descend to 17 000 feet, and level off. Our airspeed is ... 130? Now that we are level the aircraft slows to 120. And we now have to hold the attitude to within 1 degree for the next 15.8 hours or we descend.

I must be missing something here :smt017. For a given power setting and density altitude, the aircraft will fly a certain speed (provided you are on the front side of the power curve). How does this speed change if we are slowing down to it instead of speeding up to it?
---------- ADS -----------
 
Four1oh
Rank 10
Rank 10
Posts: 2448
Joined: Thu Apr 06, 2006 9:24 pm

Re: Set Cruise Power?

Post by Four1oh »

I'll bet the same people using the "200' extra and descend" technique are the same guys who, on floats, think that oscillating the elevator helps you get on step faster... I flew floats AND the HS748, the 748 being one of the doggiest airplanes above 10000' I've ever flown. The 200' cheat didn't work worth a shit on that plane either. If you think you need to do that trick to gain speed, you shouldn't be that high for your weight/performance.
---------- ADS -----------
 
Drinking outside the box.
frontside_air
Rank 2
Rank 2
Posts: 88
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 9:34 am
Location: on someone else's vacation

Re: Set Cruise Power?

Post by frontside_air »

our bird is kind of a dog near service ceiling when heavy (esp with the soul-crushing eng A/I on) and is happy to suck-hole all day after level off if you somehow got on the slow side of the profile drg the climb. climbing an extra 100'/200' to get on the step is a drop in the bucket and doesn't net any appreciable change (you need more like a 1000' FLC descent but this does help as evidenced by the AOA).

as far as rocking on the step in a floatplanes- each airframe is different and responds to different things. i always preferred to the combination technique of dropping the water rudders and "pedal-paddling" (all ahead flank!) coupled with the acceleration surge from coarsing out the prop repeatedly(cavitate!) to accelerate those last 5 knots on to the step*

if she's getting sloppy at altitude you can always try the ole TWA841 trick of pulling the slat CB and extending a notch of flap to make the plane fly "truer"(as i understand it this is actually one aspect of the dugan STC)...just make sure you tell the f/o about it after he/she comes back from the lav so he/she doesn't reset it causing the slats to extend and the roller coaster ride that ensues...then retracting them only to have the slats retract asymmetrically leading to a spiral dive and going supersonic in a B727*



*darwin disclaimer
---------- ADS -----------
 
iflyforpie
Top Poster
Top Poster
Posts: 8132
Joined: Tue Apr 15, 2008 12:25 pm
Location: Winterfell...

Re: Set Cruise Power?

Post by iflyforpie »

If you can maintain altitude at 120, but lose it at 115 and 125, you are close to your absolute altitude, you probably spent all day getting there, and unless your purpose is to vault a mountain range (probably not a good idea without excess power available) there is no point in doing it.

Like I said earlier, Vx and Vy become equal at your absolute altitude and you can only fly at the now unified Vx/Vy at altitude.

There is also another speed called Vz which is your minimum level flight speed. To reach this speed at lower altitudes involves flying at maximum throttle and the minimum airspeed possible and maintaining level flight. It's fun in a 172 with a few thousand feet of altitude for a few minutes, but it is no way to operate an aircraft.

But at your absolute altitude Vz is now equal to Vy and Vx. It is no longer on the back side of the power curve (anything on the backside will make you descend) but all of the wonderful handling qualities of the aircraft way on the back side of the power curve are still there.
frontside_air wrote: if she's getting sloppy at altitude you can always try the ole TWA841 trick of pulling the slat CB and extending a notch of flap to make the plane fly "truer"(as i understand it this is actually one aspect of the dugan STC)...just make sure you tell the f/o about it after he/she comes back from the lav so he/she doesn't reset it causing the slats to extend and the roller coaster ride that ensues...then retracting them only to have the slats retract asymmetrically leading to a spiral dive and going supersonic in a B727*
The Dugan flap droop mod is to allow the 727 to cruise at lower speeds (instead of the fuel guzzling Mach it was designed to cruise at) with a lower nose attitude (helps the F/As pushing meal carts around), not to increase its altitude to keep it from flying sloppy.
---------- ADS -----------
 
Geez did I say that....? Or just think it....?
Four1oh
Rank 10
Rank 10
Posts: 2448
Joined: Thu Apr 06, 2006 9:24 pm

Re: Set Cruise Power?

Post by Four1oh »

frontside_air wrote:our bird is kind of a dog near service ceiling when heavy (esp with the soul-crushing eng A/I on) and is happy to suck-hole all day after level off if you somehow got on the slow side of the profile drg the climb. climbing an extra 100'/200' to get on the step is a drop in the bucket and doesn't net any appreciable change (you need more like a 1000' FLC descent but this does help as evidenced by the AOA).

as far as rocking on the step in a floatplanes- each airframe is different and responds to different things. i always preferred to the combination technique of dropping the water rudders and "pedal-paddling" (all ahead flank!) coupled with the acceleration surge from coarsing out the prop repeatedly(cavitate!) to accelerate those last 5 knots on to the step*

if she's getting sloppy at altitude you can always try the ole TWA841 trick of pulling the slat CB and extending a notch of flap to make the plane fly "truer"(as i understand it this is actually one aspect of the dugan STC)...just make sure you tell the f/o about it after he/she comes back from the lav so he/she doesn't reset it causing the slats to extend and the roller coaster ride that ensues...then retracting them only to have the slats retract asymmetrically leading to a spiral dive and going supersonic in a B727*



*darwin disclaimer

I'm just going to assume you're "tongue-in-cheek" instead of actually replying to this. ;)
---------- ADS -----------
 
Drinking outside the box.
User avatar
bezerker
Rank 5
Rank 5
Posts: 340
Joined: Mon Feb 16, 2004 2:05 pm
Location: YVR

Re: Set Cruise Power?

Post by bezerker »

Many people here have obviously never been in a situation where the 200 ft descent to add speed may be necessary. I believe that in most aircraft nowadays, it probably isn't.

I don't know anything about the "step" in larger aircraft, but here is when a slight descent proved useful to me:

Pre-RVSM days, remember the 4,000' altitude changes for the same direction of flight? So, we have a choice, FL330 or FL370 today (or FL350 and FL390). Any lower and we waste too much gas and won't make it home (TEB-YYC for example) and would also have to make alternate customs/FBO/etc. arrangements. Learjets might have been different, but there are a few crusty old jets that didn't have a stellar reserve of thrust through about FL350.

So, we get to FL330 on the approved climb schedule (270/0.70 or whatever) and the bird is flying well, it is actually almost barber-polling after leveling off. But, we are burning too much gas. So, throttle back or climb to FL370 are the options. Nobody likes to throttle back, the book says we can do it, so up we go.

Things go well up to about FL350, but now she will only climb at 300 fpm at 0.70, so we have to pitch up a bit to keep her going. Now we are climbing at 0.65 through FL360 and the rate of climb is getting pathetic again. The indicated speed is getting down to almost 200 kts, and the controls are very, very mushy. It is actually slightly scary with the autopilot on when it has to make corrections for slight turbulence.

It is time for our "I hope ATC doesn't notice" climb profile. Level off for a minute or so, until the speed builds up to 220-230 kias, then climb (1/2 degree pitch up for 1-2 minutes) until it bleeds off to 200-210 kias or so, and repeat. Usually you can get 2-300 feet higher with every cycle.

The last 3 or 400 feet are brutal. We are only gaining 100 feet per cycle and the bird barely accelerates up to about 210/215 kias when we level off each time (we are too scared that ATC will tell us to go back down if we wait any longer during the acceleration phase. ATC frequency changes during this phase are gifts from God).

So, we finally get to 370, but we sure as shit don't stop there. The final stage of this routine climb profile is to continue climbing until ATC give us a WTF. If you were lucky you could get 400 ft higher than cruise before ATC freaked out. If you were unlucky and had a sharp cookie monitoring your pathetic climb gradient, you had to ignore him until you got at least 300 ft high and then use the "sorry, we didn't hear your last 12 transmissions, as we were getting the wx."

So, now level at FL374 and at about 210 kias/0.65 I guarantee that if you just stayed level, the speed would build at a rate of about 1 kt every 5 minutes for the next 2 hours (if that). It is brutal, just wallowing with the nose about 5 degrees up. We fortunately have 400 ft (or more) to build speed with though.

So, wait as long as possible at FL374 (timing is critical because ATC guy is probably really pissed by now), then start a descent down. There was always a question of do we pitch down a bunch and hopefully build a big whollup of speed or do a very gradual descent with a gradual build of speed. I always went slowly.

The key to whether it was going to work or not was the pitch attitude. If you could get the nose down to about 2-3 degrees nose up without an excessive descent rate (more than 200 fpm) you were in good shape. With luck, you could level off at FL370 or a bit lower at FL368 with a speed of 225/230 kias /0.71M. Some days the load of Direct TV recievers and 66ers of booze in the back would cause the speed to bleed back down to unhappy levels. If the pitch stayed at 4-5 degrees, you weren't going to accelerate. You could then either ride it out or go back down.

The speed would eventually build back up to 0.76+ after 2-3 hrs or so of fuel burnoff and it would be decision time again (do we go for the hallowed FL410?).

Was it worth it? Who knows, if we just throttled back at the lower altitude, we wouldn't have wasted a lot more gas I suppose. But the question here on the forum was why do it or is it ever necessary? Well, it sure seemed that at some pitch attitudes (around 5+ degrees), there wasn't a hope in hell of accelerating at high altitude. If you could get the nose down just one or 2 degrees, you could build up some speed and maintain it. The only way to do it was to descend. If you could pull it off, you could save 300+ lbs of fuel per hour (over 4-5 hrs, you add an extra hour of flying) for the sacrifice of about 20-30 kts TAS for an hour or 2.

There was another way to do it and that was to use the 30 min climb ITT limit for level off and acceleration. I have gotten into trouble with that several times however, because at some point you have to reduce to cruise ITT and hold your breath that the speed wouldn't drop to unacceptable levels, which it often did. Generally if you could get to the altitude with cruise power, using the step climb method, you could maintain it.
---------- ADS -----------
 
You're not drunk if you can lie on the floor without holding on
Four1oh
Rank 10
Rank 10
Posts: 2448
Joined: Thu Apr 06, 2006 9:24 pm

Re: Set Cruise Power?

Post by Four1oh »

oh deah GAWD! :roll:
---------- ADS -----------
 
Drinking outside the box.
AuxBatOn
Rank 11
Rank 11
Posts: 3283
Joined: Wed Jan 16, 2008 6:13 pm
Location: North America, sometimes

Re: Set Cruise Power?

Post by AuxBatOn »

What about throttle back at FL330, burn some gas, get lighter THEN request for higher, when you can actually make it? It's probably just as efficient (if not more) than doing what you suggest!
---------- ADS -----------
 
Going for the deck at corner
iflyforpie
Top Poster
Top Poster
Posts: 8132
Joined: Tue Apr 15, 2008 12:25 pm
Location: Winterfell...

Re: Set Cruise Power?

Post by iflyforpie »

The most efficient would be to do a gradual (but pathetic and would never be approved) climb to altitude at the most efficient speed. This is in effect what the Concorde used to do as its weight changed drastically throughout the flight and it was so high up it wasn't going to conflict with any traffic by being at various altitudes. With supersonic aircraft it is important to keep the speed up or the engines will never deliver the required thrust.
---------- ADS -----------
 
Geez did I say that....? Or just think it....?
frontside_air
Rank 2
Rank 2
Posts: 88
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 9:34 am
Location: on someone else's vacation

Re: Set Cruise Power?

Post by frontside_air »

iflyforpie: i stand corrected

Four1oh: indeed
bezerker wrote: Things go well up to about FL350, but now she will only climb at 300 fpm at 0.70, so we have to pitch up a bit to keep her going. Now we are climbing at 0.65 through FL360 and the rate of climb is getting pathetic again. The indicated speed is getting down to almost 200 kts, and the controls are very, very mushy. It is actually slightly scary with the autopilot on when it has to make corrections for slight turbulence.

It is time for our "I hope ATC doesn't notice" climb profile. Level off for a minute or so, until the speed builds up to 220-230 kias, then climb (1/2 degree pitch up for 1-2 minutes) until it bleeds off to 200-210 kias or so, and repeat. Usually you can get 2-300 feet higher with every cycle.

The last 3 or 400 feet are brutal. We are only gaining 100 feet per cycle and the bird barely accelerates up to about 210/215 kias when we level off each time (we are too scared that ATC will tell us to go back down if we wait any longer during the acceleration phase. ATC frequency changes during this phase are gifts from God).
^oh yeah, coupled with some light chop, Eng A/I on in cloud trying to get on top of the line of weather coming up 20 mins down the road, all topped off with a "410 is available as long as you're there in XX minutes" from atc since everyone else has the same idea...
---------- ADS -----------
 
ahramin
Rank Moderator
Rank Moderator
Posts: 6326
Joined: Tue Feb 17, 2004 5:21 pm
Location: Vancouver

Re: Set Cruise Power?

Post by ahramin »

frontside_air:

I couldn't comment on sculling the water rudders to get on the step :shock: but as for as for TWA841, there is a mountain of evidence that points to a slat malfunction rather than the crazy story the NTSB came up with.

berzerker:

:shock: :shock: :shock:

Doesn't sound like good risk management to me but if you got away with it ... :D
---------- ADS -----------
 
dgeb
Rank 0
Rank 0
Posts: 13
Joined: Mon Feb 28, 2005 1:40 pm

Re: Set Cruise Power?

Post by dgeb »

Past or present, the notion of step cruising, and the techniques used – drift down 200ft; or Clb Pwr to desired airspeed, is a transient solution. If your not getting the airspeed the Performance Charts suggest there must be something amiss. Degraded performance because of aircraft degradation or flawed WT&B calculations.

The solution for getting the extra 10% performance in airspeed inevitably becomes adding a little extra power to get a large return in airspeed. Just enough power to keep on the front side of the curve!!
---------- ADS -----------
 
User avatar
Cap'n P8
Rank 7
Rank 7
Posts: 715
Joined: Mon Feb 16, 2004 7:23 pm
Location: Dorval (rarely)

Re: Set Cruise Power?

Post by Cap'n P8 »

x-wind wrote:KAG, didn't like the "the airplane is lighter with an AFT loading" no it produces less drag. Less weight and less drag are different. Just wanted to mention that.
Actually...since C of G is ahead of C of P, and that couple produces a nose down moment which the tailplane has to counter with down force (lift), the effective weight (actual weight + down force) of the airplane must be considered. If the C of G is moved aft (closer to the C of P) the nose down couple will be reduced, the required down force of the tailplane will be less and the a/c will effectively weigh less. This of course means the a/c will be flying at a lower angle of attack since less lift is required to remain at a level altitude and this will result in better cruise performance.
---------- ADS -----------
 
"Hell, I'll fly up your ass if the money's right!"
Orlando Jones - Say It Isn't So
iflyforpie
Top Poster
Top Poster
Posts: 8132
Joined: Tue Apr 15, 2008 12:25 pm
Location: Winterfell...

Re: Set Cruise Power?

Post by iflyforpie »

Aft loading still doesn't change the weight of the plane, just how much the wings have to support.
---------- ADS -----------
 
Geez did I say that....? Or just think it....?
User avatar
Cap'n P8
Rank 7
Rank 7
Posts: 715
Joined: Mon Feb 16, 2004 7:23 pm
Location: Dorval (rarely)

Re: Set Cruise Power?

Post by Cap'n P8 »

Of course it doesn't change the ACTUAL weight, it changes the EFFECTIVE weight. It's about equilibrium of forces. If the aircraft is loaded closer to the forward C of G it will take a performance hit and behave like a heavier airplane. Same type of concept as density altitude. The a/c doesn't care about absolute altitude, it performs in relation to it's density altitude.
---------- ADS -----------
 
"Hell, I'll fly up your ass if the money's right!"
Orlando Jones - Say It Isn't So
Post Reply

Return to “General Comments”