Beaver with broken wing Porpoise Bay
Moderators: sky's the limit, sepia, Sulako, North Shore, Rudder Bug
-
sportingrifle
- Rank 6

- Posts: 413
- Joined: Wed Nov 23, 2005 2:29 am
Beaver with broken wing Porpoise Bay
Saw something very odd the other day in Porpoise Bay. (BC coast). A Beaver in the water with the rh wing broken just outboard of the strut. All ok, waiting for a tow in. Anyone know what happened? I can@t for the life of me figure out how to do that much damage without hurting anyone.
Cheers.
Cheers.
Re: Beaver with broken wing Porpoise Bay
Whose was it?? Tofino or west coast? Or was it someones private or leased machine?
Glad to hear they're all ok though.
Glad to hear they're all ok though.
Re: Beaver with broken wing Porpoise Bay
Nothing in the CADORS. When was this?
Former Advocate for Floatplane Safety
-
sportingrifle
- Rank 6

- Posts: 413
- Joined: Wed Nov 23, 2005 2:29 am
Re: Beaver with broken wing Porpoise Bay
Thursday afternoon. Not familiar with which operator. White belly with burgundy upper.
Re: Beaver with broken wing Porpoise Bay
I doubt they will report the prang.Widow wrote:Nothing in the CADORS.
One of our 412's found a crashed Air Tractor a couple of weeks back and reported it to TC - most likely the operator just got out and was going to come back with a flat bed truck.
-
Speed Boat
- Rank 0

- Posts: 1
- Joined: Sat Sep 19, 2009 7:01 pm
Re: Beaver with broken wing Porpoise Bay
It was not West Coast air. The accident is still under investigation and to support their efforts I will not release who it was...but it was definitely not WCA.
-
Taxi Driver
- Rank 2

- Posts: 85
- Joined: Tue Mar 08, 2005 9:53 am
Re: Beaver with broken wing Porpoise Bay
A Beaver struck its wing on the water during take-off in Comox Harbour this summer. The wing broke at the strut attach point.
I wonder what the odds are that the same thing happended twice in just a few months.



I wonder what the odds are that the same thing happended twice in just a few months.



Re: Beaver with broken wing Porpoise Bay
SAR_YQQ wrote:I doubt they will report the prang.Widow wrote:Nothing in the CADORS.
One of our 412's found a crashed Air Tractor a couple of weeks back and reported it to TC - most likely the operator just got out and was going to come back with a flat bed truck.
Umm, isn't it REQUIRED to report accidents?
Former Advocate for Floatplane Safety
-
iflyforpie
- Top Poster

- Posts: 8132
- Joined: Tue Apr 15, 2008 12:25 pm
- Location: Winterfell...
Re: Beaver with broken wing Porpoise Bay
It is.Umm, isn't it REQUIRED to report accidents?
But in a case like this where is was pretty obvious what caused the accident, it is pretty obvious how to prevent it, and simple to repair; reporting the accident is more likely to produce problems rather than solutions...
Geez did I say that....? Or just think it....?
Re: Beaver with broken wing Porpoise Bay
And what kind of problems would be faced if caught not reporting the accident?
Former Advocate for Floatplane Safety
-
Taxi Driver
- Rank 2

- Posts: 85
- Joined: Tue Mar 08, 2005 9:53 am
Re: Beaver with broken wing Porpoise Bay
I would imagine that nothing would happen. TC is truly a toothless tiger.
Widow was the one in Comox Reported? How about the one in Nanaimo?
Widow was the one in Comox Reported? How about the one in Nanaimo?
Re: Beaver with broken wing Porpoise Bay
Hey look ...
I was a little disturbed at the near miss between a Salt Spring Island DHC2 and two Harbour Air DHC3-Ts not being investigated and publically reported on by the TSB.
And can anyone tell me what "unit in the accessory case" could fail and cause a total engine failure and emergency landing? (Also a TSB Class "5" investigation).
Taxi driver, I found all kinds of interesting stuff I didn't know about when I searched CADORS for the two incidents you mentioned. I did find a WCA report from late May out of Comox ... but nothing that looked like it was out of Nanaimo.CADORS Number: 2009P1473 Reporting Region: Pacific
Occurrence InformationOccurrence Type: Accident Occurrence Date: 2009/09/17
Occurrence Time: 1755 Z Day Or Night: day-time
Fatalities: 0 Injuries: 0
Canadian Aerodrome ID: Aerodrome Name:
Occurrence Location: Porpoise Bay (Sechelt, BC) Province: British Columbia
Country: CANADA World Area: North America
Reported By: TSB AOR Number:
TSB Class Of Investigation: 5 TSB Occurrence No.: A09P0316
Event InformationLoss of control - on ground
Runway excursion
Aircraft InformationFlight #:
Aircraft Category: Aeroplane Country of Registration: CANADA
Make: DEHAVILLAND - CAN Model: DHC 2 MKI
Year Built: 1959 Amateur Built: No
Engine Make: PRATT & WHITNEY-USA Engine Model: R-985-AN-14B
Engine Type: Reciprocating Gear Type: Sea
Phase of Flight: Landing Damage: Substantial
Owner: TOFINO AIR LINES LTD Operator: TOFINO AIR LINES LTD. (4937)
Operator Type: Commercial
Detail InformationUser Name: Bowyer, Brent
Date: 2009/09/23
Further Action Required: Yes
O.P.I.: Commercial & Business Aviation
Narrative: A09P0316: The Tofino Air DHC-2 Mk. 1 float-equipped aircraft, C-FHRT, took off from Porpoise Bay for a local training flight. The aircraft made a practice landing into wind in Sechelt Inlet. As the aircraft was slowing down on the step the right float dug into the water, the aircraft turned 90 degrees to the right, and the right wingtip struck the water. The pilots were uninjured; the aircraft was substantially damaged.
I was a little disturbed at the near miss between a Salt Spring Island DHC2 and two Harbour Air DHC3-Ts not being investigated and publically reported on by the TSB.
And can anyone tell me what "unit in the accessory case" could fail and cause a total engine failure and emergency landing? (Also a TSB Class "5" investigation).
Former Advocate for Floatplane Safety
-
Taxi Driver
- Rank 2

- Posts: 85
- Joined: Tue Mar 08, 2005 9:53 am
Re: Beaver with broken wing Porpoise Bay
What possible solution could the TBS come up with to prevent another near miss?
-
Double Wasp
- Rank 3

- Posts: 142
- Joined: Sun Feb 29, 2004 12:08 am
Re: Beaver with broken wing Porpoise Bay
Widow wrote:
Anything that can cause an oil leak can cause an engine failure ie: starter, generators etc.
As well some engines have fuel and oil pumps run from an accessory case. The "pilot cooling fan" stops turning very quickly after either one of these stops.
DW
GenerallyAnd can anyone tell me what "unit in the accessory case" could fail and cause a total engine failure and emergency landing?
Anything that can cause an oil leak can cause an engine failure ie: starter, generators etc.
As well some engines have fuel and oil pumps run from an accessory case. The "pilot cooling fan" stops turning very quickly after either one of these stops.
DW
When it stops leakin oil then you worry.
Re: Beaver with broken wing Porpoise Bay
Those pictures are from today? I know those colors yet heard nothing about itTaxi Driver wrote:A Beaver struck its wing on the water during take-off in Comox Harbour this summer. The wing broke at the strut attach point.
I wonder what the odds are that the same thing happended twice in just a few months.
Re: Beaver with broken wing Porpoise Bay
Glad to see that other than some brownish underwear...noone was hurt. 
Last edited by ALF on Thu Sep 24, 2009 9:51 am, edited 1 time in total.
-
Taxi Driver
- Rank 2

- Posts: 85
- Joined: Tue Mar 08, 2005 9:53 am
Re: Beaver with broken wing Porpoise Bay
no the pictures are from early summer.
whats wrong with tofino air? i have always liked flying with them.
whats wrong with tofino air? i have always liked flying with them.
Re: Beaver with broken wing Porpoise Bay
I guess that depends on the sequence of events that allowed it to happen. I'd like to think other operators and ATS will be given the opportunity to learn something. Did you read the CADORS on it? Maybe there will be something in a TC Safety Letter about it, since the TSB doesn't produce one anymore.Taxi Driver wrote:What possible solution could the TBS come up with to prevent another near miss?
The pics don't look like they belong to the WCA incident in Comox in late May that are in the CADORS. Another operator then ... ? And, when was the Nanaimo incident you mentioned?
Last edited by Widow on Thu Sep 24, 2009 11:01 am, edited 1 time in total.
Reason: to correct operator name
Reason: to correct operator name
Former Advocate for Floatplane Safety
-
CoastFloater
- Rank 1

- Posts: 31
- Joined: Mon Aug 31, 2009 1:57 pm
Re: Beaver with broken wing Porpoise Bay
Widow wrote:I guess that depends on the sequence of events that allowed it to happen. I'd like to think other operators and ATS will be given the opportunity to learn something. Did you read the CADORS on it? Maybe there will be something in a TC Safety Letter about it, since the TSB doesn't produce one anymore.Taxi Driver wrote:What possible solution could the TBS come up with to prevent another near miss?
The pics don't look like they belong to the WCA incident in Comox in late May that are in the CADORS. Another operator then ... ? And, when was the Nanaimo incident you mentioned?
That was WCA's aircraft and subsequent pictures from May in Comox. WCA runs ex-baxter beavers...hence the colours. If I recall correctly, it was either 207 (C-GEZS) that dipped the wing. 205 went on the recovery mission from sechelt base for pilot and passengers who were all ok and in good spirits. The aircraft was back online with a different wing and primered aeleron a couple days later. I think we can all be glad that these incidents are becoming less and less frequent due to better learning/teaching practices, may years of operational lessons, better decision making, etc.
Float flying's a dynamic environment...it could happen to anyone, and has happened to many. This is what I remind myself regularly so as to be on the side of caution and not cowboy.
Re: Beaver with broken wing Porpoise Bay
Did this incident involve a cowboy? It could happen to anyone? What?? There are many of us flying on the coast with thousands of hours of 'this not happening", and frankly in much more challenging conditions. How is it that we don't have this problem? Are the rest of us just that lucky? The most important lesson from this event should be the build up to it, and how that led to an incident." Float flying's a dynamic environment...it could happen to anyone, and has happened to many. This is what I remind myself regularly so as to be on the side of caution and not cowboy." ?????
-
mag check
- Rank 7

- Posts: 631
- Joined: Sat Sep 22, 2007 6:24 am
- Location: Drink in my hand, feet in the sand
Re: Beaver with broken wing Porpoise Bay
This would be classed as an accident, not an incident. A reportable incident is only for aircraft over 5700 kg.buck82 wrote:Did this incident involve a cowboy? It could happen to anyone? What?? There are many of us flying on the coast with thousands of hours of 'this not happening", and frankly in much more challenging conditions. How is it that we don't have this problem? Are the rest of us just that lucky? The most important lesson from this event should be the build up to it, and how that led to an incident." Float flying's a dynamic environment...it could happen to anyone, and has happened to many. This is what I remind myself regularly so as to be on the side of caution and not cowboy." ?????
Aircrat under 5700kg only have accidents, or reportable occurances, never incidents.
We're all here, because we're not all there.
Re: Beaver with broken wing Porpoise Bay
Thanks for clarifying the accident incident thing

