Citation down North of Kelowna
Moderators: sky's the limit, sepia, Sulako, lilfssister, North Shore
Re: Citation down North of Kelowna
Terrible news, condolences to all family and friends
"It has been my experience that folks who have no vices have very few virtues." - Abraham Lincoln (1809 - 1865)
Re: Citation down North of Kelowna
Well .. okay ..your post is made 305pm.ragbagflyer wrote:Nothing of any significance.fixedpitch wrote:
So no icing conditions were present in the area at the time?
FYI there's a radar image publicized for 9:40pm last night shown on CBC 3:45pm today by Chris, of the wx network. Seems there ... if you performed a right turnout at YLW off rwy16 for climbout west could encounter markedly different precip in climb than in the left turnout into a northeast climbout east of Kelowna.
Re: Citation down North of Kelowna
Jim Prentice was an outstanding Canadian.oldncold wrote:The 3? I have are
1) was there a strong jet stream or Mountain wave in the Kelowna area those have been known to exceed 3000ft min
2)medical issues
3) did aircraft have inflight structural failure
Note this is not speculation. But?
To his family I was fortunate to have met him 1 once. When he was industry minister. Also he took the time to answer my opposition to the sale of mc Donald Dwettwiller to ALLIANZ. Re sar sat 2 technology it spoke volumes to me about the kind of guy he was. My sincere condolences to his family and to also to the families of all on board.
Good judgment comes from experience. Experience often comes from bad judgment.
Re: Citation down North of Kelowna
I spent a fair amount of time sitting in a relative's house at Black Mountain in Rutland this summer and every jet I saw coming of 16 climbed straight ahead and abeam Black Mountain started a climbing left turn for eastern points.pdw wrote:Well .. okay ..your post is made 305pm.ragbagflyer wrote:Nothing of any significance.fixedpitch wrote:
So no icing conditions were present in the area at the time?
FYI there's a radar image publicized for 9:40pm last night shown on CBC 3:45pm today by Chris, of the wx network. Seems there ... if you performed a right turnout at YLW off rwy16 for climbout west could encounter markedly different precip in climb than in the left turnout into a northeast climbout east of Kelowna.
Do we know they departed off 16. The METAR seems to favor 34, no?
Good judgment comes from experience. Experience often comes from bad judgment.
Re: Citation down North of Kelowna
The Star has this report, naming another passenger...DanWEC wrote:Jim Prentice, former AB premiere, was aboard the plane. RIP to all.
https://www.thestar.com/news/canada/201 ... crash.html
Good judgment comes from experience. Experience often comes from bad judgment.
Re: Citation down North of Kelowna
Just saw an aerial view of the crash site, it appears to have gone in vertical, no trail of debris, just the impact area. I hope there is a CVR and FDR for a hopefully quick report!
Re: Citation down North of Kelowna
Doesn't look like much left.mbav8r wrote:Just saw an aerial view of the crash site, it appears to have gone in vertical, no trail of debris, just the impact area. I hope there is a CVR and FDR for a hopefully quick report!
Anybody comment on that last readout 120 knots and -2200 fpm at 4800 feet.
Good judgment comes from experience. Experience often comes from bad judgment.
Re: Citation down North of Kelowna
Was there not a typhoon hitting western BC that day? Looking at the weather didn't seem very nice. Where did you get the-2000fm stat?daedalusx wrote:A) No it hasn't. Not in CYLW lately.upup_away wrote:There has been some nasty weather over Western Canada lately.
B) Theres no wx that would cause you to go -2000fpm on a 500. Even on 1 engine.
- Siddley Hawker
- Rank 11
- Posts: 3353
- Joined: Tue Aug 10, 2004 6:56 pm
- Location: 50.13N 66.17W
Re: Citation down North of Kelowna
https://aviation-safety.net/database/re ... 20161013-0Where did you get the-2000fm stat?
-
- Rank 11
- Posts: 4581
- Joined: Mon Feb 16, 2004 2:33 am
- Location: YYC 230 degree radial at about 10 DME
Re: Citation down North of Kelowna
Can't imagine a structural failure causing a light descent rate like that although Flightracker isn't always super accurate, physiological issue, TR deploy, SVR TURBC maybe. The picture on CBC looked like the V stab and one H stab survived, not much else.Siddley Hawker wrote:https://aviation-safety.net/database/re ... 20161013-0Where did you get the-2000fm stat?
CBC said pilot and 3 pax. Not sure if that's accurate, don't know of many single pilot jet ops in Canada. Condolences.
-
- Rank 8
- Posts: 775
- Joined: Fri Jul 19, 2013 5:19 pm
Re: Citation down North of Kelowna
There are definitely a number of jets being flown single-pilot in Canada.
Re: Citation down North of Kelowna
News is reporting the identity of the single pilot, JK. Also the third passenger. Very sad day for everyone.
- oldncold
- Rank (9)
- Posts: 1015
- Joined: Thu May 13, 2004 11:17 am
- Location: south of 78N latitude , north of 30'latitude
Re: Citation down North of Kelowna
Correct re solo pic jet the good thing is these days, Flt safety n Simcom won't issue spic jet to those ( good for all concerned,public and industry alike).that cut their training program. Which brings me to the dark side. As part of any normal investigation of hi profile individuals. One must ask the following? 1) who would gain the most in J.P. Death (due to the political influence and principles he held fast to) and 2 was the aircraft tampered with. Failure to ask these? And eliminate them will always leave the conspiring theorists. To? The out come of the tsb final report. Once again my condolences to the family
Re: Citation down North of Kelowna
It in Flight Aware, their last reliable hit, I think.upup_away wrote:Was there not a typhoon hitting western BC that day? Looking at the weather didn't seem very nice. Where did you get the-2000fm stat?daedalusx wrote:A) No it hasn't. Not in CYLW lately.upup_away wrote:There has been some nasty weather over Western Canada lately.
B) Theres no wx that would cause you to go -2000fpm on a 500. Even on 1 engine.
I thought 120 knots and -2200 fpm gives a strange setup, no? That has to be pretty much power off, doesn't it?
CB?
The RCMP officer said in one of the stories that there were very heavy rains at the time.
Not sure if I have the crash site accurate, but it does seem that from the 7000 foot altitude to the last hit at 4800, he was able to maintain course, or at least roughly.
Good judgment comes from experience. Experience often comes from bad judgment.
Re: Citation down North of Kelowna
From the looks of it, I think this is going to be a difficult investigation. They won't be able to determine if medical factors were involved, everything looks to be in bits.oldncold wrote:Correct re solo pic jet the good thing is these days, Flt safety n Simcom won't issue spic jet to those ( good for all concerned,public and industry alike).that cut their training program. Which brings me to the dark side. As part of any normal investigation of hi profile individuals. One must ask the following? 1) who would gain the most in J.P. Death (due to the political influence and principles he held fast to) and 2 was the aircraft tampered with. Failure to ask these? And eliminate them will always leave the conspiring theorists. To? The out come of the tsb final report. Once again my condolences to the family
Good judgment comes from experience. Experience often comes from bad judgment.
Re: Citation down North of Kelowna
With respect, I don't think the political and sabotage investigations are really necessary. Jim Prentice was a moderate conservative who was greatly admired across the political spectrum.oldncold wrote:Correct re solo pic jet the good thing is these days, Flt safety n Simcom won't issue spic jet to those ( good for all concerned,public and industry alike).that cut their training program. Which brings me to the dark side. As part of any normal investigation of hi profile individuals. One must ask the following? 1) who would gain the most in J.P. Death (due to the political influence and principles he held fast to) and 2 was the aircraft tampered with. Failure to ask these? And eliminate them will always leave the conspiring theorists. To? The out come of the tsb final report. Once again my condolences to the family
Good judgment comes from experience. Experience often comes from bad judgment.
Re: Citation down North of Kelowna
Can someone pm me the name of the pilot? Oscar posted jk I hope it's not who I think it is
Re: Citation down North of Kelowna
1st hit is 2min after takeOff doing 160kts at 4000', then 3000' per minute climb to 7000' at 150kt /3min mark. Next/last hit is down to 4800ft at 120kts, 4min after takeoff (the 3 radar hits info on flightaware, plus the take-off time given as 9:32 local).
Average flightaware speed is 130-140kts over the 4 min, which works out to about 8-9 nautical miles flown in that time, yet the distance between the airport to the accident site is 6 nautical miles and approx 1nm mile up. Winds near calm at surface at ylw 9pm local, so ASN "rwy16" info looks possible.
Average flightaware speed is 130-140kts over the 4 min, which works out to about 8-9 nautical miles flown in that time, yet the distance between the airport to the accident site is 6 nautical miles and approx 1nm mile up. Winds near calm at surface at ylw 9pm local, so ASN "rwy16" info looks possible.
Last edited by pdw on Sat Oct 15, 2016 5:50 am, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Citation down North of Kelowna
Autopilot fail & subsequent loss of control? SP-IFR, private ops, near vertical impact. Just speculating.
-
- Rank 7
- Posts: 683
- Joined: Sat Sep 17, 2005 9:27 am
- Location: Toronto
Re: Citation down North of Kelowna
Attitude instrument failure not caught in time could do it.
One of the early Citation crashes happened because the pilot had jumped in and got in the air before the gyros had spooled up.
One of the early Citation crashes happened because the pilot had jumped in and got in the air before the gyros had spooled up.