davecessna wrote:It's tough, he is a veritable wealth of knowledge. However, we have several, with all due respect, more advanced generation members on this site who are equally knowledgeable, but aren't almost always hostile pricks.
My favourite CS moment was when some guy was asking some perhaps ill-advised questions about training and CS chimed in with the usual, calling the new generation "a bunch of coddled pansies". The guy then responded, "I just completed 2 tours in Afghanistan".
CS did not respond to the thread after that.
Invoking 'tour of duty' into that discussion commanded respect, as you've witnessed, while that silences it unfortunately as well.
The nephew came back from two tours there, and the remarkable thing is, was seriously nervous/concerned preparing to go out that first time. Sure happy to be back .... a different man, very thankful, commands respect, happily married with two kids, and very pleasant to talk to.
I didn't see an issue of silencing great discussion; was more about keeping it going, notwithstanding any variably agressive quirks the sensitive are so quick to object on. If the "equally knowledgeable" get too carefull, the topics bog down or reduce ... and sometimes that's good... but going out on a limb to say something solid ... taking some risk ... keeps things alive for responders to contemplate.
Adjustment for thread drift ... this was about contemplating purchase of a Piper Cub or similar price-range (and an associated reality check).