With your permission, I'll ignore the sneer in your tone (perhaps I'm imagining it), and try to present a thoughtful answer.Big Pistons Forever wrote: ↑Wed Aug 17, 2022 9:34 pm
So how about explaining exactly how you would expect the average pilot to maintain proficiency in the turn back maneuver and what is your expectation for what constitutes proficient?
I don't think maintaining proficiency at this kind of manoeuvre differs very much from any other kind of manoeuvre: occasional practice, and if occasional practice shows a drop in proficiency, then perhaps more training and more frequent practice would be indicated.
Proficiency might be, in a typical light trainer, the ability to reverse course in a gliding steep turn in not more than 300 feet of vertical descent, depending on the performance characteristics of the aircraft, and the ability to bring the aircraft to the correct configuration, attitude and trim to achieve that turn, from any configuration of power, within the prior few seconds.
One can practice this at higher altitude, and then in a more realistic scenario from an altitude of 1000 agl after takeoff, and then 500 agl after takeoff, with appropriate permission from any ATC authority that applies. A low approach to the airport infield followed by climbing away, or to a parallel or crossing runway, will give a good idea of what could have been achieved in a real emergency. It may even be possible, depending on winds and runways, to land on a runway. If it becomes clear that a suitable touchdown spot could not have been achieved, then this is valuable training too, since the pilot will learn that a turn-back from whenever it was initiated, would not have resulted in a safe landing.
Of course if one is not confident of how to do any of this, or one feels that ones ability to control the aircraft risks being compromised, then perhaps some dual instruction with a competent instructor would be the best place to start. Some familiarity with the characteristics of the airplane as it approaches and goes into an accelerated power-off stall (maintaining a 45° banked turn) will be helpful.
Further advice can also be found in TP13747.
If you're willing to discuss specifics of how to achieve better, I'm open for it. If you're merely hoping I'll trail a target for you to take shots at, well, there you go. I don't think there's any magic sauce, if that's what you're looking for.