This is for YYZ right? May I ask when you interviewed / how long after the interview they offered you the spot?atcguy98 wrote: ↑Thu Apr 07, 2022 4:23 pmThanks, seeing that answer to 1) really sucks considering that I can't really take the opportunity, but I appreciate you confirming my suspicion. I may try to get out of work on one of the 2 days which were available but it's not looking like that will be possible.M1bmx wrote: ↑Thu Apr 07, 2022 4:02 pm1. That's probably a good assumption. When I did my test I was told they were doing a lot of hiring this year, plus they may be having an issue with no-shows, so they've expanded eligibility.atcguy98 wrote: ↑Thu Apr 07, 2022 2:44 pm I just received an invite to an in-person test which I was super excited about - until I saw that it's next week. Unfortunately, I don't think I can attend unless I take a day off of work but we're super busy at the moment, and even if I did the stress of this busy period would probably hamper my performance.
I was hoping to get some clarification if anyone is more familiar:
1) Is it reasonable to assume that because in my email they said something along the lines of "we had a few extra spots so we decided to invite you" on such short notice, it would mean that I was probably below the online test cut-off for the "normal" invites, and they just happened to invite me as well since they had extra space? If I don't take it, do you think that there is a low chance I will get invited later on as well because this time it just seems that I was lucky to not have others who scored better than me attend?
2) Does anyone know when the next set of these in-person tests (specifically YYZ) would be, and if these in-person tests run on Saturdays/Sundays or only on weekdays?
I have no idea if you'll get invited later but, if I were you, I would see it as an opportunity and take it.
2. At the FIR I applied to, they have two intakes per year. I would assume this means they only test twice per year. When I signed up I didn't see any weekend testing.
Any updates on training?
Moderators: sky's the limit, sepia, Sulako, North Shore
Re: Any updates on training?
Re: Any updates on training?
I’m assuming the invite is for FEAST. In my opinion you should go, is one day off work worth it to have a shot at an amazing career? If you’re that concerned about not being in the right mindset, take off the day before too. That’s what I’d do.
I’ve heard about multiple FIRs having no-shows to FEAST. I’d take your invite as a win and attend.
I’ve heard about multiple FIRs having no-shows to FEAST. I’d take your invite as a win and attend.
Re: Any updates on training?
Unfortunately, I just started interning in a job I'm really enjoying and I'm worried about approaching my boss for a day or two off during a hectic time without any really good reason... I don't think I should say I'm skipping to go pursue something else lol, and I feel it's unfair to them to give a days notice (I'd have to go for the Monday test and let them know tomorrow). I agree though, I think I should go as it would be a waste of an amazing opportunity not to. Thanks for the adviceyoshi91 wrote: ↑Thu Apr 07, 2022 7:16 pm I’m assuming the invite is for FEAST. In my opinion you should go, is one day off work worth it to have a shot at an amazing career? If you’re that concerned about not being in the right mindset, take off the day before too. That’s what I’d do.
I’ve heard about multiple FIRs having no-shows to FEAST. I’d take your invite as a win and attend.
Edit to update: the only day I would've been able to go is now gone. I guess that's what happens when you wait too long. Here's to hoping for another invitation in the future.
Another update! Checked again and another session came up next week on a day that actually works better than Monday - I guess someone must have withdrawn, but I've booked it
Last edited by atcguy98 on Fri Apr 08, 2022 8:15 am, edited 4 times in total.
Re: Any updates on training?
This isn't regarding an interview, it's about the in-person test (FEAST) after the online test.sk1996 wrote: ↑Thu Apr 07, 2022 7:06 pmThis is for YYZ right? May I ask when you interviewed / how long after the interview they offered you the spot?atcguy98 wrote: ↑Thu Apr 07, 2022 4:23 pmThanks, seeing that answer to 1) really sucks considering that I can't really take the opportunity, but I appreciate you confirming my suspicion. I may try to get out of work on one of the 2 days which were available but it's not looking like that will be possible.M1bmx wrote: ↑Thu Apr 07, 2022 4:02 pm
1. That's probably a good assumption. When I did my test I was told they were doing a lot of hiring this year, plus they may be having an issue with no-shows, so they've expanded eligibility.
I have no idea if you'll get invited later but, if I were you, I would see it as an opportunity and take it.
2. At the FIR I applied to, they have two intakes per year. I would assume this means they only test twice per year. When I signed up I didn't see any weekend testing.
Re: Any updates on training?
I don’t think there’s an interview before FEASTyoshi91 wrote: ↑Thu Apr 07, 2022 7:16 pm I’m assuming the invite is for FEAST. In my opinion you should go, is one day off work worth it to have a shot at an amazing career? If you’re that concerned about not being in the right mindset, take off the day before too. That’s what I’d do.
I’ve heard about multiple FIRs having no-shows to FEAST. I’d take your invite as a win and attend.
Just the online stuff
Re: Any updates on training?
atcguy98 wrote: ↑Thu Apr 07, 2022 7:49 pmOh looks like I misunderstood sorrysk1996 wrote: ↑Thu Apr 07, 2022 7:06 pmThis is for YYZ right? May I ask when you interviewed / how long after the interview they offered you the spot?atcguy98 wrote: ↑Thu Apr 07, 2022 4:23 pm
Thanks, seeing that answer to 1) really sucks considering that I can't really take the opportunity, but I appreciate you confirming my suspicion. I may try to get out of work on one of the 2 days which were available but it's not looking like that will be possible.
This isn't regarding an interview, it's about the in-person test (FEAST) after the online test.
-
- Rank 1
- Posts: 47
- Joined: Mon Mar 07, 2022 3:06 pm
Re: Any updates on training?
sk1996 wrote: ↑Wed Apr 06, 2022 9:03 am
Just so you know you won't lose your mortgage as long as you keep up your payments. Now the feasibility of that with a pay cut is a different issue.
I'm juggling the decision right now, I genuinley think this is a job that I would enjoy compared to what I am doing now/will be doing in the future. I'm willing to take a pay cut for that. I also don't really care about the money. It's more so just feeling as though I am actually doing something worthwhile.
Unfortunately I went with a private lender and my renewal is coming up this year, maybe I will able to bypass it if the timing is right, renewal is over the summer so I might be able to to trick them. But the bigger issue is my mortgage would be like 2/3 of my monthly income @ 48K/year which is not ideal.kevenv wrote: ↑Wed Apr 06, 2022 4:02 amOnce you have a mortgage banks don't keep checking to see how much you make, calling in the mortgage if you have a change of circumstances. So long as you keep up the payments they don't care that you changed jobs or took a pay cut. Now come renewal you might have an issue....vultajolma wrote: ↑Tue Apr 05, 2022 9:20 pm Personally I am likely to decline, especially given the fact I would lose my mortgage due to the massive paycut and being on probation the whole time.
I agree this is something I would want to try and worth living frugally for a while but alot of things have to go right for me, I definitely wont take any VFR/FSS offers, only IFR in the YYZ region which is pretty narrow.
Good luck on your interview by the way!
Re: Any updates on training?
Isn’t vfr and ifr similarly paid?vultajolma wrote: ↑Fri Apr 08, 2022 12:36 amsk1996 wrote: ↑Wed Apr 06, 2022 9:03 am
Just so you know you won't lose your mortgage as long as you keep up your payments. Now the feasibility of that with a pay cut is a different issue.
I'm juggling the decision right now, I genuinley think this is a job that I would enjoy compared to what I am doing now/will be doing in the future. I'm willing to take a pay cut for that. I also don't really care about the money. It's more so just feeling as though I am actually doing something worthwhile.Unfortunately I went with a private lender and my renewal is coming up this year, maybe I will able to bypass it if the timing is right, renewal is over the summer so I might be able to to trick them. But the bigger issue is my mortgage would be like 2/3 of my monthly income @ 48K/year which is not ideal.kevenv wrote: ↑Wed Apr 06, 2022 4:02 amOnce you have a mortgage banks don't keep checking to see how much you make, calling in the mortgage if you have a change of circumstances. So long as you keep up the payments they don't care that you changed jobs or took a pay cut. Now come renewal you might have an issue....vultajolma wrote: ↑Tue Apr 05, 2022 9:20 pm Personally I am likely to decline, especially given the fact I would lose my mortgage due to the massive paycut and being on probation the whole time.
I agree this is something I would want to try and worth living frugally for a while but alot of things have to go right for me, I definitely wont take any VFR/FSS offers, only IFR in the YYZ region which is pretty narrow.
Good luck on your interview by the way!
Thank you! I think I’ll be fine. May have over prepped a bit even haha
Re: Any updates on training?
Just curious, how does over 30 have anything to do with FSS? There are people of all ages in all streams.naribari wrote: ↑Thu Apr 07, 2022 3:54 pmThis was my experience during my FEAST test as well. Not only that, everyone other than me seemed to be over the age of 30 meaning they were probably applying for FSS anyway.kevenv wrote: ↑Sun Apr 03, 2022 4:44 amATC2B wrote: ↑Sat Apr 02, 2022 6:54 pm
I wonder if there's a serious need to get people into training asap and not enough capacity to pull people from the beginning (ie time to have people come in and do FEAST) that might be why your FEAST score is now good for an interview when it wasn't before... just pure speculation
QM ACC did 2 weeks of FEAST testing recently. I was told that some days only 3 of the 10 that were scheduled actually showed up.
Re: Any updates on training?
IFR is paid more than VFR, especially if you end up working at a lower traffic tower. Might be able to make the difference in OT though?sk1996 wrote: ↑Fri Apr 08, 2022 9:26 amIsn’t vfr and ifr similarly paid?vultajolma wrote: ↑Fri Apr 08, 2022 12:36 amsk1996 wrote: ↑Wed Apr 06, 2022 9:03 am
Just so you know you won't lose your mortgage as long as you keep up your payments. Now the feasibility of that with a pay cut is a different issue.
I'm juggling the decision right now, I genuinley think this is a job that I would enjoy compared to what I am doing now/will be doing in the future. I'm willing to take a pay cut for that. I also don't really care about the money. It's more so just feeling as though I am actually doing something worthwhile.Unfortunately I went with a private lender and my renewal is coming up this year, maybe I will able to bypass it if the timing is right, renewal is over the summer so I might be able to to trick them. But the bigger issue is my mortgage would be like 2/3 of my monthly income @ 48K/year which is not ideal.kevenv wrote: ↑Wed Apr 06, 2022 4:02 am
Once you have a mortgage banks don't keep checking to see how much you make, calling in the mortgage if you have a change of circumstances. So long as you keep up the payments they don't care that you changed jobs or took a pay cut. Now come renewal you might have an issue....
I agree this is something I would want to try and worth living frugally for a while but alot of things have to go right for me, I definitely wont take any VFR/FSS offers, only IFR in the YYZ region which is pretty narrow.
Good luck on your interview by the way!
Thank you! I think I’ll be fine. May have over prepped a bit even haha
I would argue that VFR training is shorter though, so they'd be making a full-time wage sooner than going IFR - but they'd run the risk of being positioned at a tower outside of the GTA. Pros and cons either way. Good luck on your interviews and assessments!
Re: Any updates on training?
"Be age 30 or under (on the closing date of the application period)"kashep wrote: ↑Fri Apr 08, 2022 9:34 amJust curious, how does over 30 have anything to do with FSS? There are people of all ages in all streams.
https://www.faa.gov/levelup
The American version of ATC is a lot more harsh in this regard, but the reality is true in NAVcan as well.
viewtopic.php?t=66366
This old thread shows the attitudes and policies.
To be honest, before going in this forum, it was my belief that the 30 years old cut off was explicit for ATC. I was sure I had read it, but now I can't find it. Whatever the case, the attitude is there, the imperative is there, the counterpart does it explicitly, old people fail more often in training and are less intellectually agile in general. Personally, I'm under 30 and I'm still feeling bad about my age because I'm not 22 which I feel is probably the optimal age they're looking for.
Obviously NAVCAN isn't hiring 55 years olds to train them for ATC. Are they hiring 45 year olds? What about 35 year olds?
If the hiring selection looks like a bell curve, it's a bad sign for over 30s. I've done training for a few other jobs, in every single one of them the over 40s struggle to keep up. Obviously this isn't an environment where they got extensively tested like NAVCAN does, but the concerns are still there.
Edit: If someone is really motivated to know, they could always ATIP navcan.
-
- Rank 0
- Posts: 7
- Joined: Fri Apr 08, 2022 12:58 pm
Re: Any updates on training?
I received notification on Tuesday that I passed the FEAST - anyone in YQM getting invited for interviews yet? Just curious if I’ll be in limbo for a while or not called at all (it is what it is just wondering thanks)
Re: Any updates on training?
I received 2 FSS offers last year (I declined both). I was 45. I noted my preference was IFR throughout the process.naribari wrote: ↑Fri Apr 08, 2022 11:41 am"Be age 30 or under (on the closing date of the application period)"
https://www.faa.gov/levelup
The American version of ATC is a lot more harsh in this regard, but the reality is true in NAVcan as well.
viewtopic.php?t=66366
This old thread shows the attitudes and policies.
To be honest, before going in this forum, it was my belief that the 30 years old cut off was explicit for ATC. I was sure I had read it, but now I can't find it. Whatever the case, the attitude is there, the imperative is there, the counterpart does it explicitly, old people fail more often in training and are less intellectually agile in general. Personally, I'm under 30 and I'm still feeling bad about my age because I'm not 22 which I feel is probably the optimal age they're looking for.
Obviously NAVCAN isn't hiring 55 years olds to train them for ATC. Are they hiring 45 year olds? What about 35 year olds?
If the hiring selection looks like a bell curve, it's a bad sign for over 30s. I've done training for a few other jobs, in every single one of them the over 40s struggle to keep up. Obviously this isn't an environment where they got extensively tested like NAVCAN does, but the concerns are still there.
Edit: If someone is really motivated to know, they could always ATIP navcan.
-
- Rank 1
- Posts: 47
- Joined: Mon Mar 07, 2022 3:06 pm
Re: Any updates on training?
IFR does pay more, but for me its about the location, two years ago I was ready to move anywhere but not anymore. For VFR/FSS you are essentially guaranteed to be outside GTA region at a lower tower which is better for passing but I dont want to wait 3-5 years or more in order to transfer out, while you are almost guaranteed to be at the same FIR you train at for IFR route.
-
- Rank 2
- Posts: 78
- Joined: Thu Feb 22, 2018 7:09 pm
Re: Any updates on training?
Yes and yes. And I’ve seen them all succeed too.naribari wrote: ↑Fri Apr 08, 2022 11:41 am Are they hiring 45 year olds? What about 35 year olds?
Re: Any updates on training?
Are you going to try for ATC again? What's your outlook?evilgravy wrote: ↑Fri Apr 08, 2022 5:55 pmI received 2 FSS offers last year (I declined both). I was 45. I noted my preference was IFR throughout the process.naribari wrote: ↑Fri Apr 08, 2022 11:41 am"Be age 30 or under (on the closing date of the application period)"
https://www.faa.gov/levelup
The American version of ATC is a lot more harsh in this regard, but the reality is true in NAVcan as well.
viewtopic.php?t=66366
This old thread shows the attitudes and policies.
To be honest, before going in this forum, it was my belief that the 30 years old cut off was explicit for ATC. I was sure I had read it, but now I can't find it. Whatever the case, the attitude is there, the imperative is there, the counterpart does it explicitly, old people fail more often in training and are less intellectually agile in general. Personally, I'm under 30 and I'm still feeling bad about my age because I'm not 22 which I feel is probably the optimal age they're looking for.
Obviously NAVCAN isn't hiring 55 years olds to train them for ATC. Are they hiring 45 year olds? What about 35 year olds?
If the hiring selection looks like a bell curve, it's a bad sign for over 30s. I've done training for a few other jobs, in every single one of them the over 40s struggle to keep up. Obviously this isn't an environment where they got extensively tested like NAVCAN does, but the concerns are still there.
Edit: If someone is really motivated to know, they could always ATIP navcan.
Re: Any updates on training?
My experience is there are people of all ages in all streams. Maybe younger is more common but there is certainly no 30 year cut off for ATC in Canada. If you can get through recruitment and training you're good to go. I started FSS training when I was 25 and I was the oldest in the course. First postings for FSS are often remote, I would say many 30+ are not willing to make that move and are actually less likely to be applying for FSS.naribari wrote: ↑Fri Apr 08, 2022 11:41 am"Be age 30 or under (on the closing date of the application period)"
https://www.faa.gov/levelup
The American version of ATC is a lot more harsh in this regard, but the reality is true in NAVcan as well.
viewtopic.php?t=66366
This old thread shows the attitudes and policies.
To be honest, before going in this forum, it was my belief that the 30 years old cut off was explicit for ATC. I was sure I had read it, but now I can't find it. Whatever the case, the attitude is there, the imperative is there, the counterpart does it explicitly, old people fail more often in training and are less intellectually agile in general. Personally, I'm under 30 and I'm still feeling bad about my age because I'm not 22 which I feel is probably the optimal age they're looking for.
Obviously NAVCAN isn't hiring 55 years olds to train them for ATC. Are they hiring 45 year olds? What about 35 year olds?
If the hiring selection looks like a bell curve, it's a bad sign for over 30s. I've done training for a few other jobs, in every single one of them the over 40s struggle to keep up. Obviously this isn't an environment where they got extensively tested like NAVCAN does, but the concerns are still there.
Edit: If someone is really motivated to know, they could always ATIP navcan.
Re: Any updates on training?
No - this was my third run at it. I'm good!naribari wrote: ↑Sat Apr 09, 2022 12:22 amAre you going to try for ATC again? What's your outlook?evilgravy wrote: ↑Fri Apr 08, 2022 5:55 pmI received 2 FSS offers last year (I declined both). I was 45. I noted my preference was IFR throughout the process.naribari wrote: ↑Fri Apr 08, 2022 11:41 am
"Be age 30 or under (on the closing date of the application period)"
https://www.faa.gov/levelup
The American version of ATC is a lot more harsh in this regard, but the reality is true in NAVcan as well.
viewtopic.php?t=66366
This old thread shows the attitudes and policies.
To be honest, before going in this forum, it was my belief that the 30 years old cut off was explicit for ATC. I was sure I had read it, but now I can't find it. Whatever the case, the attitude is there, the imperative is there, the counterpart does it explicitly, old people fail more often in training and are less intellectually agile in general. Personally, I'm under 30 and I'm still feeling bad about my age because I'm not 22 which I feel is probably the optimal age they're looking for.
Obviously NAVCAN isn't hiring 55 years olds to train them for ATC. Are they hiring 45 year olds? What about 35 year olds?
If the hiring selection looks like a bell curve, it's a bad sign for over 30s. I've done training for a few other jobs, in every single one of them the over 40s struggle to keep up. Obviously this isn't an environment where they got extensively tested like NAVCAN does, but the concerns are still there.
Edit: If someone is really motivated to know, they could always ATIP navcan.
Re: Any updates on training?
The NavCan thread is 12 years old. I don't think it was true back then on what age is acceptable and certainly not now.naribari wrote: ↑Fri Apr 08, 2022 11:41 am "Be age 30 or under (on the closing date of the application period)"
https://www.faa.gov/levelup
The American version of ATC is a lot more harsh in this regard, but the reality is true in NAVcan as well.
viewtopic.php?t=66366
I believe the American standard has more to do with the ability to earn a 25 year operational pension than it does your abilities above 30. They have mandatory retirement at 55. We don't.
I have seen young people fail and older people fail. If you are interested in the job apply. Don't pay attention to anyone who tells you you are too old or that NavCan doesn't like to hire above a certain age. Some people "get" the job and others don't. I don't think there is a magic test. If there was one ANS providers around the world would be all over it. As an aside my last new qualification was done at 56. Granted I am in the job..... still, you are never too old to learn something new.
-
- Rank 0
- Posts: 7
- Joined: Fri Apr 08, 2022 12:58 pm
Re: Any updates on training?
Do you know if QM ACC is inviting people for interviews yet? I passed the FEAST and just wondering if I’m not making the cut this time around.kevenv wrote: ↑Sun Apr 03, 2022 4:44 amATC2B wrote: ↑Sat Apr 02, 2022 6:54 pm
I wonder if there's a serious need to get people into training asap and not enough capacity to pull people from the beginning (ie time to have people come in and do FEAST) that might be why your FEAST score is now good for an interview when it wasn't before... just pure speculation
QM ACC did 2 weeks of FEAST testing recently. I was told that some days only 3 of the 10 that were scheduled actually showed up.