Privatized airports, this will go well!

Discuss topics relating to airlines.

Moderators: sky's the limit, sepia, Sulako, North Shore

Post Reply
cdnavater
Rank 10
Rank 10
Posts: 2923
Joined: Wed Apr 21, 2021 11:25 am

Privatized airports, this will go well!

Post by cdnavater »

It’s been bad under the non profit system, why would anyone think privatization would be better for the consumer, friggen politicians and their spin doctoring!
https://globalnews.ca/news/11822472/can ... -minister/
The federal government is in the “early stages” of talks on whether Canada’s airports will be privatized, Transport Minister Steven MacKinnon told reporters on Wednesday.


When asked if the government was considering privatizing airports and if so, how many, MacKinnon told reporters that the government was talking with airport authorities.

“We’re in the early stages of a process with airport authorities and other partners to determine the best way forward. The ultimate goal, of course, is to improve the passenger experience, to improve the efficiency of our air transport system,” MacKinnon said.

The government is working with NAV Canada and the Canadian Air Transport Security Authority to finalize the plan, he said, although he did not say whether this included handing over airport land entirely to private players or plans to have public-private partnerships.

“Indeed, they are a public good and I don’t think that spirit or that philosophy will change,” he said.
When asked if money from investment in Canada’s airports will be funneled into Canada’s new sovereign wealth fund, MacKinnon said, “I don’t think that any determination has been made on that front.”

The federal government is considering inviting private investment into Canada’s airports, according to the Spring Economic Update.
The federal government says it is working to “unlock the full potential” of Canada’s airports by exploring “alternative models of ownership.”

“The government is also assessing opportunities to unlock the full value of airports in support of investments in Canada’s long-term growth, including through alternative models of ownership, the spring economic update says.

“This work will be advanced with the input of the airport authorities and other stakeholders including airlines and local governments,” the document says.

This is not the first time the Mark Carney government has hinted at privatizing Canada’s airports. In the federal budget presented in November 2025, the federal government said it will “consider options for the privatization of airports.”

As of 2020, nearly 20 per cent of the airports in the world had been privatized. A 2022 study in the U.S.-based non-profit National Bureau of Economic Research compared the performance of 2,444 airports around the world in 217 countries
The report found that the number of passengers per flight — a key metric when assessing airport efficiency — increased by 20 per cent when private equity funds buy government-owned airports and overall passenger traffic rises by 84 per cent.

Airports also get bigger with private equity funds as owners, the report found, with private owners adding new terminals and gates. The study also found fewer flight cancellations.

However, flying may get more expensive as the fees that airports charge to airlines rises after an airport is privatized, the report found. The rise in the number of privately-owned airports was also associated with a push for deregulation and pushback against government controls, such as caps or limits on fees.

In the early 1990s, Canada chose to retain public ownership of airports but transferred operations of some of the busiest airports in the country to 21 privately owned airport authorities.

Canada currently has 23 airports that are leased to 21 private airport authorities by Transport Canada, with Mirabel International Airport and Pierre Elliott Trudeau Airport in Montreal operated by the same authority.

The federal government collects up to 12 per cent of airport gross revenues in the form of rent, the Canadian Airports Council says. Between 1992 and 2019, airports have paid more than $6.5 billion in “rent” to the federal government, the council says.
---------- ADS -----------
 
TheStig
Rank 8
Rank 8
Posts: 888
Joined: Thu Nov 10, 2011 12:34 pm

Re: Privatized airports, this will go well!

Post by TheStig »

Based on how Hwy 407 was sold and how users are gouged it's easy to be skeptical of this proposal. However, I like the idea of a sovereign wealth fund and I have issues with how our airports are operated now and this could be a huge improvement.

Canada's airport authorities are bloated, fiscally reckless and have little oversight. I think the government would need to put foreign ownership and price controls in place but the privatizing separate portions of airports operations; such as de-icing, surface area maintenance, etc could provide more competition and lower costs. I also believe that if airlines are allowed to purchase terminals they could be operated more efficiently and with greater cost controls to improve passenger movement and lower cost.
---------- ADS -----------
 
User avatar
‘Bob’
Rank (9)
Rank (9)
Posts: 1142
Joined: Fri Apr 23, 2021 10:19 am

Re: Privatized airports, this will go well!

Post by ‘Bob’ »

If you think fees are high and services are terrible now….

Private enterprise only works with ruthless competition.

Without that… you need such a comprehensive and effective watchdog that it might as well be public.
---------- ADS -----------
 
Tanker299
Rank 3
Rank 3
Posts: 189
Joined: Tue Jan 12, 2010 7:16 am

Re: Privatized airports, this will go well!

Post by Tanker299 »

The federal government seems to be overlooking its own role in why Canadian airports are so expensive in the first place.

Airport authorities already operate on a self-funded model, yet they’re required to pay significant rent back to Ottawa. In most cases, rent paid on infrastructure is reinvested into what is being rented —maintenance, upgrades, and expansion. That’s not happening here. Instead, airports are forced to fund all capital and operating costs through user fees while also sending rent to the federal government. It’s a structural cost driver.

On top of that, security costs through Canadian Air Transport Security Authority are passed directly to passengers, and pricing isn’t standardized in a way that reflects a national transportation system. A simplified, consistent fee structure across all destinations would improve transparency and reduce friction. At most airports it’s the same security line unless you are going to America… $9ish bucks in Canada $12ish for the states and almost $40 anywhere else.

If affordability and efficiency are the real goals, there are straightforward policy levers available:

* Eliminate federal rent unless it’s going back into said airport
* Standardize security fees.
* Regulate AIFs and Ldg fees

Privatization doesn’t address the root issue—it risks layering profit expectations on top of an already expensive system. 407 is at times a buck a KM…

Finally, competition is often cited as a solution, but most Canadian cities simply don’t have the population base to support multiple major airports. Realistically, only regions like Toronto Pearson alongside Billy Bishop and Hamilton, or Montréal–Dorval with potential re development at Montréal–Mirabel and continued growth at St Hubert, could create meaningful competition—and even that would be limited.

Before pursuing privatization, it would make more sense to fix the cost structure the government itself created.
---------- ADS -----------
 
Post Reply

Return to “General Airline Industry Comments”